
A leaking bath faucet can be frustrating, especially when it's happening while you're trying to relax in the shower. The good news is that most leaky faucets can be fixed with a few simple adjustments.
Loose connections are a common culprit behind leaky faucets. Check if the faucet's handle or aerator is loose, as this can cause water to drip out.
A worn-out O-ring or gasket is another possible cause. These parts can become damaged over time, allowing water to seep out. In some cases, the O-ring or gasket may be damaged due to mineral buildup, which can be a sign of hard water in your area.
Broaden your view: Kitchen Faucet
Causes of the Leak
A faulty diverter valve is the primary cause of a leaky bathtub faucet when the shower is on. This valve is responsible for diverting water from the tub spout to the showerhead.
The diverter valve can fail due to three common reasons: a broken seal from wear and tear, corroded or cracked inner threads, or a corroded or chipped finish or caulking.
Additional reading: Shower Hot and Cold Valve Replacement
A worn-out washer or improper installation can also cause a leak. The washer is a component inside the faucet that can get worn down over time, leading to water leakage.
Faucet cartridge issues, such as a failing cartridge or worn-down parts, can also cause a leak. This can result in water dripping from the tub spout or trouble controlling the temperature.
Here are the possible causes of a leaky bathtub faucet when the shower is on:
- Broken seal from wear and tear
- Corroded or cracked inner threads
- Corroded or chipped finish or caulking
- Faulty diverter valve
- Faucet cartridge issues
- Failing faucet stem
A failing faucet stem can also cause a leak, as it can break and water can begin to flow freely.
Mineral Buildup from Hard Water
Mineral buildup from hard water is a common culprit behind leaky bathtub faucets. It occurs when there's a higher mineral content, usually calcium and magnesium, in the water.
These dissolved minerals build up in your pipes and fixtures over time, causing less water to pass through. This buildup can lead to a leaky faucet, especially when the shower is on and water pressure is lower.
Here's an interesting read: What Does It Mean When Your Aircon Leaks Water
You might notice other signs of hard water alongside mineral buildup on your showerhead. For example, you might feel a film on your hands after washing them, or notice dull clothes or hair after washing.
Here are some other common signs of hard water:
- Spots on your freshly-washed dishes
- Calcium deposits on your shower walls
- Dry and itchy skin
Hard water can cause mineral buildup to occur, leading to a leaky faucet.
What Causes Leaks?
Leaks can be frustrating and wasteful, but understanding what causes them can help you fix the issue. Broken seals from wear and tear are a common reason for leaks.
There are several parts that can contribute to leaks, including the faucet cartridge, which helps control water temperature and regulate water flow. You'll know it's going bad if you see water dripping from the tub spout or if you have trouble controlling the temperature.
Worn-out washers or improper installation can also cause leaks. This is especially common in compression faucets, which require compression to seal the space. If the washer doesn't form a proper seal, you can see water dripping from the spigot.
If this caught your attention, see: Bottom of Shower Door Seal

Other possible causes include mineral buildup from hard water, which can cause less water to pass through and result in leaks. Hard water is characterized by higher mineral content, usually calcium and magnesium.
Here are some common signs of hard water:
- Feeling like there is a film on your hands after you wash them
- Dull clothes or hair after you’ve washed them
- Spots on your freshly-washed dishes
- Calcium deposits on your shower walls
- Dry and itchy skin
A failing faucet stem can also cause leaks, as it's a small lever that lifts up and down to control the water flow. If it breaks, water can begin to leak.
A faulty diverter valve can also cause leaks, especially when the shower is on. This valve diverts water from the tub spout up to the showerhead, but if it's faulty, water can leak from the tub spout instead.
In some cases, the leak may be caused by corrosion or damage to the inner threads or finish of the shower diverter valve. Regular maintenance and inspection can help prevent these issues.
A different take: Toilet Tank Leaks When Flushing
Bath
Replacing worn-out or corroded parts can fix a leaky bathtub faucet. You can find replacement parts at hardware stores and home centers, but a plumbing parts distributor may have a wider selection.
To ensure a proper match, bring your old parts to the store for comparison. Thousands of different faucet replacement parts are available, so it's essential to get the right ones.
Replacing the entire faucet is often the best option if the valve is highly corroded or the finish is wearing off. This can be a cost-effective solution in the long run, especially if you're handy with DIY plumbing repairs.
Intriguing read: Faucet Water Pipes
Understanding the Shower Diverter
The shower diverter valve is the mechanism that controls where your water flows. It's usually found at the end of your tub spout.
The diverter valve has a simple job: to direct water from the tub faucet to the showerhead when you want to take a shower. Closing the valve diverts the water into the showerhead, while opening it allows the water to flow directly through the tub faucet.
If the diverter valve fails, not all the water goes into the showerhead, causing your tub faucet to leak when the shower is on. This is often due to worn-out seals, corroded or cracked inner threads, or a chipped or corroded finish.
Here are the three common reasons shower diverters fail:
- Broken seal from wear and tear
- Corroded or cracked inner threads
- Corroded or chipped finish or caulking
Failed Shower Diverter
A failed shower diverter can be frustrating, especially when you're trying to enjoy a relaxing shower. The shower diverter valve is the mechanism that lets you change where your water flows, typically found at the end of your tub spout.
It's usually a simple matter of opening or closing the valve to direct the water to the tub faucet or showerhead. However, if the valve fails, it can cause your tub faucet to leak when the shower is on.
There are three common reasons shower diverters fail: broken seals from wear and tear, corroded or cracked inner threads, and corroded or chipped finishes or caulking.
If you're not sure what's causing the issue, it's a good idea to check for mineral buildup in your fixtures first. Removing mineral deposits can sometimes resolve the problem. But if that doesn't work, you may have a failed shower diverter valve.
If you decide to try and fix the issue yourself, you can start by checking the spout for a small hole or set screw. If you find one, you can use an Allen wrench to remove the screw and twist the spout off the copper supply pipe.
Here's an interesting read: Cost of Converting Bath to Walk in Shower
However, if you don't have the time or confidence to tackle the repair yourself, it's always best to call a professional plumber. They can quickly diagnose the issue and get your shower working properly again.
Here are the common reasons shower diverters fail:
- Broken seal from wear and tear
- Corroded or cracked inner threads
- Corroded or chipped finish or caulking
Introduction
Don't put up with the frustration of a leaky shower diverter, nor with the growing stain it often leaves behind. Fixing it is easier and cheaper than you think.
Leaky shower diverters can cause slow drips and unsightly stains, but they're often fixable with the right tools. You can prevent these headaches and save on your water bill by taking action.
Worn-out parts like rubber washers, seals, or gaskets are common causes of leaks in shower diverters. With the right tools, you can identify and replace these parts.
Here are the tools you'll need to get started:
- Adjustable wrench
- Bath socket wrench
- Handle puller
- Seat wrench
- Utility knife
Fixing a leaky shower diverter can be a DIY-friendly project, and it's far less expensive than hiring a plumber.
Figure A: Tub Parts and Assembly

Understanding the Shower Diverter requires a basic knowledge of tub parts and assembly. This is crucial for making repairs and replacements.
The bathtub faucet stem is a critical component that needs to be replaced or repaired occasionally. To do this, you'll need to lubricate the parts with special plumber's grease.
You'll also need to replace the washers and seats in both the hot and cold valves if you're working on a two-handalled faucet. This will ensure a smooth and leak-free operation.
Here's a step-by-step guide to replacing the stem and other parts:
- Unpack the new parts and read the instructions carefully.
- Lubricate the stem threads and reinstall the stem in the bonnet.
- Grease the new packing washer and slide it in place, then grease the packing nut threads and firmly tighten the packing nut.
- Remove the old seat washer screw and the old seat washer, and replace them with new ones.
- Apply pipe joint compound to the bonnet threads and reinstall it in the faucet body.
- Grease the handle splines and replace the escutcheon and faucet handle.
Remember to use special plumber's grease throughout the process to ensure a smooth and leak-free operation.
Fixing the Problem
The first step to fixing a bath faucet leaking when the shower is on is to identify the source of the leak. This can be a broken seal from wear and tear, corroded or cracked inner threads, or a corroded or chipped finish or caulking.
To fix the problem, you can either replace part of or the entire shower diverter valve. In some cases, simply replacing the rubber washer may be enough to fix the issue.
Removing the faucet handle is often the toughest part of the job, as corrosion can virtually weld the handle to the stem. To access the valve, you may need special tools or professional assistance.
If you're not comfortable attempting the repair yourself, you can always call a plumber to take care of it for you. Expert licensed plumbers are available 24/7 to get your shower working properly again in no time.
Common reasons shower diverters fail include a broken seal from wear and tear, corroded or cracked inner threads, and corroded or chipped finish or caulking.
Here are some steps to disassemble the faucet:
- Shut off the water supply to the faucet and open the water shutoff valves to drain excess water from the system.
- Pry off the handle insert with the thin blade of a pocketknife.
- Remove the screw that holds the shower diverter valve in place.
- Take out the rubber washer and replace it, if necessary.
If you're not comfortable with DIY repairs, it's best to call a plumber to avoid any further damage or stress.
Preparation and Safety
Before you start working on your bath faucet, it's essential to prepare and ensure your safety. Turn off the water supply to the faucet to prevent water from flowing out while you work.
You'll still have some water left in the pipes connected to the faucet, so turn it on to empty the rest of the water before getting started. This is especially important if you're working on a faucet that's been leaking when the shower is on.
Cover the drain of the tub to prevent small components like washers and bolts from falling down the drain while you work. This simple step can save you a lot of hassle and frustration in the long run.
Shutting off the main water supply valve is a good idea if you can't find a valve to turn off just the tub or bathroom water. This will temporarily turn off the water throughout your home, giving you a safe and dry working environment.
Here's an interesting read: Toilet Water Valve Leaking
Testing and Verification
Put the faucet back together and see how it works. Carefully fit the pieces back together, ensuring that you tighten any screws and bolts securely.
Turn the water back on to verify that you have corrected the problem in your bathtub faucet. Check the original leaky area to ensure there is no longer a problem.
Featured Images: pexels.com


